| Rey Arizmendi | Defense | Monroe Community College |
| Danield Binene | Forward | Mercyuhrst University - North East |
| Justin Fuller | Forward | Mercyuhrst University - North East |
| Hector Corrales | Midfield/GK | Mercyhurst University - North East |
| Nic Fischer | Goalkeeper | Monroe Community College |
| Santieno Harding | Forward | Monroe Community College |
| Garrett Hunderford | Midfield | Monroe Community College |
| Jakup Husenovic | Goalkeeper | Mercyhurst University - North East |
| Eric Longhorn | Defense | Monroe Community College |
| Saad Mohacht | Forward | Monroe Community College |
| Simoni Surwavuba | Midfield | Mercyuhrst University - North East |
| Player of the Year | ||
| Santieno Harding | Forward | Monroe Community College |
| Coach of the Year | ||
| Craig Dewar | Monroe Community College | |
