First Team |
||
| Rodrigo Albuquerque | Forward | Genesee Community College |
| Shemar Blair | Forward | Herkimer College |
| Dylan Bridger | Defense | Onondaga Community College |
| Charlie Desforges | Midfield | SUNY Broome Community College |
| Sam Hall | Midfield | Genesee Community College |
| Mupenzi Irakiza | Midfield | Herkimer College |
| Kent Meier | Midfield | Cayuga Community College |
| Erick Ramos Mejia | Defense | Mohawk Valley Community College |
| Shahin Tahir Nasabi | Defense | Genesee Community College |
| Ed Port | Forward | Genesee Community College |
| Santiago Rojas | Goalkeeper | Mohawk Valley Community College |
| Marius Svendsen | Defense | Herkimer College |
| Spencer Urquiza | Forward | Cayuga Community Colege |
Second Team |
||
| Chris Capaldo | Forward | Herkimer College |
| Richard Cochran | Defense | Tompkins Cortland Community College |
| Bryan Drossell | Defense | Hudson Valley Community College |
| Gian-Luca Failing | Defense | Herkimer College |
| Stian Klausen | Goalkeeper | Herkimer College |
| James Lighton | Midfield | Genesee Community College |
| Derek McArthur | Midfield | Finger Lakes Community College |
| Gabriel Mendoza | Forward | Finger Lakes Community College |
| Cameron Neira | Defense | SUNY Broome Community College |
| Isaak Somow | Midfield | Mohawk Valley Community College |
| Grant Stamp | Forward | Cayuga Community College |
| Mwibeleca Tumba | Midfield | Erie Community College |
| Ismar Turkovic | Forward | SUNY Broome Community College |
Player of the Year |
||
| Rodrigo Albuquerque | Forward | Genesee Community College |
Coach of the Year |
||
| Ken Gavin | Genesee Community College | |
